4 Best Island to Live on in Hawaii

Choosing the best island to live on in Hawaii is like picking your favorite gem out of a treasure chest – each one has its own unique charm, sparkle, and appeal. Let’s dive in to find the perfect island for you.

What are the Key Factors to Consider When Choosing an Island?

Relocating to Hawaii isn’t just a change of scenery – it’s a major lifestyle shift. You’ll need to weigh the factors that align with your needs, lifestyle, and dreams. Let’s break down the most important factors you should think about.

Cost of Living

• Housing Costs: Hawaii is known for its high housing costs. The beautiful scenery comes with a price tag. Housing options, from rental apartments to owning a place, vary from island to island. Oahu, particularly Honolulu, is the most expensive, while Kauai and the Big Island may offer more affordable housing markets.
• Daily Expenses: Groceries, dining out, and utilities are higher than mainland standards. The “Aloha Tax” means you’ll be paying a premium for goods imported to the islands, even for things like fruit trees or milk.
• Utilities and Energy: Energy costs in Hawaii are some of the highest in the country due to reliance on imported oil. Solar energy is a popular alternative to offset these expenses.

Accessibility and Transportation

• Public Transportation: On Oahu, the public transportation system is fairly comprehensive. TheBus (Oahu’s bus system) covers most major areas, offering typical fares cheaper than owning a car. This is great for those living near Waikiki Beach or other populated areas like Pearl City. In contrast, public transportation options on Maui, Kauai, and the Big Island are more limited.
• Flight Connections: Oahu’s Honolulu International Airport (HNL) is the busiest and best-connected airport in the Hawaiian chain, making inter-island and international travel easier. Smaller islands like Lanai or Molokai have fewer flight options, which could impact accessibility.
• Traffic and Commute: Oahu, especially around Honolulu, has infamous rush hour traffic. On other islands, a slower pace of life means less congestion but fewer road options.

Community Amenities

• Healthcare: The largest hospitals are on Oahu, with Hawaii’s best healthcare facilities concentrated in Honolulu. Maui and the Big Island have smaller hospitals, but with fewer specialized services.
• Schools: If education is a top priority, Oahu has the widest range of schooling options, including private institutions like Punahou School and Iolani School.
• Shopping and Entertainment: For a bustling night life, art galleries, and shopping centers, Oahu is the epicenter, with the famous Ala Moana Center as its crown jewel. On other islands, amenities tend to be more sparse and centered around major towns.

Overview of Hawaii’s Islands

Now that we know what to consider, which are the best island to live on in Hawaii?

Oahu

• Vibe: The most populous island, Oahu is a mix of city life and natural beauty. It’s where you’ll find Waikiki Beach, Diamond Head Volcano, and Pearl Harbor.
• Major Attractions: Honolulu, Pearl Harbor, North Shore Oahu, Hanauma Bay.
• Lifestyle: Perfect for those who crave amenities, night life, historic sites, and easy access to different kinds of jobs.

Maui

• Vibe: Known for its beautiful beaches, world-class resorts, and outdoor activities, Maui offers a mix of nature and luxury. Think whale watching, stunning beaches, and famous beaches like Wailea.
• Major Attractions: Haleakala National Park, Hana Highway, Maui County, west Maui.
• Lifestyle: Great for those who appreciate nature without losing touch with community amenities.

The Big Island

• Vibe: It’s big – really big. You’ll experience everything from tropical rainforests to black sand beaches. There’s a variety of climates due to its active volcanoes and diverse landscapes.
• Major Attractions: Hawaii Volcanoes National Park, Mauna Kea, Kealakekua Bay.
• Lifestyle: A place for adventurers and those who love the outdoors.

Kauai

• Vibe: The lush, laid-back island of Kauai is famous for its natural beauty. It’s the ultimate island for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle.
• Major Attractions: Waimea Canyon, Na Pali Coast, Shipwreck Beach.
• Lifestyle: Peaceful, secluded, and nature-oriented.

Pros and Cons of Living in Oahu

Advantages of Urban Life

• Access to Amenities: Oahu has the most developed infrastructure, including hospitals, schools, shopping centers, and public transportation. Living here means you have access to the widest range of services.
• Job Opportunities: Being the hub for business and tourism, Oahu has more job opportunities compared to other islands. The island’s tourist infrastructure offers a plethora of employment in hospitality, retail, and healthcare.
• Culture and Entertainment: From cultural sites like the Polynesian Cultural Center to trendy nightlife in Waikiki, Oahu is bursting with options.

Disadvantages of Higher Living Costs

• Cost of Housing: Oahu has some of the highest housing costs in Hawaii. Honolulu in particular can be expensive, with limited selection for affordable options.
• Crowds and Traffic: If you’re hoping to escape rush hour and tourists, Oahu might not be for you. Areas like Waikiki and Honolulu can get congested, especially during peak tourist season.
• Pace of Life: Compared to outer islands, the pace of life here is faster, which may not suit those looking for a relaxed Hawaiian vibe.

Pros and Cons of Living in Maui

Family-Friendly Atmosphere

• Outdoor Recreation: Maui is full of outdoor activities perfect for families – hiking in Haleakala, snorkeling at Molokini Crater, or just relaxing at pristine beaches.
• Community Feel: Maui offers a more tight-knit community than Oahu. Living in places like Lanai City or west Maui means you’re surrounded by locals who value their connections.
• Beautiful Scenery: Maui’s famous beaches, pineapple plantations, and scenic drives (like the Road to Hana) make it visually stunning.

Potential Tourist Influx and Costs

• Tourist Destination: While Maui is less busy than Oahu, tourism is still a major industry here. Tourists flock to Lahaina, Kaanapali, and Wailea, making these areas more crowded and expensive.
• Cost of Living: Living in an island paradise comes with a cost. Maui isn’t as expensive as Oahu, but it’s still pricier than the mainland, with housing options in popular areas fetching a premium.

Pros and Cons of Living on the Big Island

Benefits of Diverse Landscapes

• Variety of Climates: The Big Island offers just about every climate – from sunny beaches to snow-capped peaks. This is a major draw for those who love diverse outdoor activities, such as hiking, snorkeling, or stargazing.
• More Space, Less Crowds: The Big Island’s size means there’s more space to breathe. Whether it’s the vast lava fields or secluded beach spots, it’s easy to find your slice of paradise without the crowds.
• Affordable Housing: Compared to Oahu and Maui, the Big Island has more affordable housing, with land available for those looking to build their own home.

Challenges with Remote Areas and Amenities

• Limited Healthcare and Shopping: The Big Island’s amenities are not as developed as Oahu’s. Healthcare facilities and shopping centers can be far apart, especially if you live in more remote areas like Puna or Kau.
• Active Volcanoes: Living on an island with active volcanoes means there’s always a risk of volcanic activity affecting your daily life. While it adds a unique beauty, it’s a factor worth considering.
• Job Market: Opportunities are fewer compared to Oahu. Most jobs are related to tourism, agriculture, or small businesses, meaning it may be challenging to find specialized work.

Pros and Cons of Living in Kauai

Appeal of a Laid-Back Lifestyle

• Slower Pace: Kauai offers the slower pace of life many people are looking for when they imagine Hawaii. It’s peaceful, less crowded, and has a strong sense of community.
• Stunning Natural Beauty: Nicknamed “The Garden Isle,” Kauai boasts lush landscapes, from Waimea Canyon to Hanalei Bay. This is the island for those who love nature, tranquility, and stunning views.
• Outdoor Activities: Hiking, kayaking, and snorkeling are abundant here. Waimea Canyon and the Na Pali Coast are just a few of the breathtaking outdoor recreation opportunities available.

Limitations on Job Opportunities

• Limited Selection of Jobs: Kauai doesn’t have the extensive job market found on Oahu. Most employment is centered around tourism or agriculture, and opportunities can be scarce in other industries.
• Higher Cost of Goods: Since it’s smaller and less developed, you’ll likely find fewer shopping options and higher prices due to goods being shipped in from other parts of the Hawaiian island chain or mainland.
• Healthcare Access: While Kauai does have healthcare facilities, they aren’t as extensive as those found on Oahu. If you require specialized medical attention, you may need to fly to another island.

Conclusion

When it comes down to it, finding the best island to live on in Hawaii depends on what matters most to you. If you want the excitement of city life, Oahu is unbeatable. If you’re dreaming of a balance between comfort and natural beauty, Maui is perfect. For adventure seekers who love variety, the Big Island offers it all. And if you’re craving tranquility and lush scenery, Kauai is the place to be. Hawaii’s beauty and pace of life offer something for everyone—it’s about finding the island that speaks to your heart.

ALSO READ: The 10 Best African Beach Resorts

FAQs